The role of landscape factors in bumble bee pathogen loads across regions of the eastern Nearctic

Pathogens and parasites are considered important drivers of declines of wild bumble bee populations. Transmission of pathogens and parasites can be influenced by numerous abiotic and biotic factors, such as floral resource availability, inter/intraspecific pollinator interactions, land use change, climate, and exposure to pesticides . Identifying the key factors in the landscape to address to reduce disease burden in bees is thus challenging. We evaluated loads of common bee viruses Black Queen Cell Virus (BQCV) and Deformed Wing Virus (DWV) in the bumble bee Bombus impatiens, as well as the honey bee Apis meliferra, and loads of bumble bee parasites Vairimorpha bombi and Crithidia bombi in B. impatiens, from sites representing diverse habitat types and quality across North Carolina. We assessed relationships between pathogen loads and land cover characteristics, floral quality metrics, bee community diversity/richness metrics, and weather variables to determine which landscape factors best explained variation in pathogen loads. We compared our results with a comparable dataset from Pennsylvania. The data support latitudinal difference in pathogen loads but that pathogen loads otherwise tend to be influenced by landscape factors similarly between states. In North Carolina bumble bees, there was very low prevalence of DWV (14% of samples) and no Vairimorpha (0% of samples) and C. bombi showed consistently moderate loads across North Carolina (99% of samples) but more variation in loads in Pennsylvania . Directionality of pathogen incidence by landscape factors for both bee species generally mirrored results from Pennsylvania, however, BQCV loads were impacted differently by floral resource availability metrics by species and region. Honey bees and bumble bees in North Carolina showed similar trends, but correlations were weaker for bumble bees. Together with data from the literature, our results suggest honey bee density and percent developed land tend to be associated with increased pathogen loads in North American bumble bees, but floral availability metrics and community composition and diversity have mixed effects on pathogen loads.

Version 2 provides the following updates: The Kruskal-Wallice tests were replaced with individual mixed-effects models looking at each comparison specifically; the original Figure 3 was removed; some individual statistical comparisons of honey bee pathogen loads were removed as they were determined outside the scope of the project; p-value matrices were created for the correlation matrices; and individual mixed effects models were run to compare pathogen loads between the Pennsylvania 2020 data to North Carolina 2022.

Citation

Gratton, Elena; Hines, Heather; Grozinger, Christina (2023). The role of landscape factors in bumble bee pathogen loads across regions of the eastern Nearctic [Data set]. Scholarsphere. https://doi.org/10.26207/12ca-gg34

Files

Metadata

Work Title The role of landscape factors in bumble bee pathogen loads across regions of the eastern Nearctic
Access
Open Access
Creators
  1. Elena Gratton
  2. Heather Hines
  3. Christina Grozinger
Keyword
  1. Anthophila
  2. Disease
  3. Epidemiology
  4. Landscape ecology
  5. Management
License CC BY-NC 4.0 (Attribution-NonCommercial)
Work Type Dataset
Publication Date 2023
DOI doi:10.26207/12ca-gg34
Related URLs
Deposited May 15, 2023

Versions

Analytics

Collections

This resource is currently not in any collection.

Work History

Version 1
published

  • Created
  • Updated
  • Added Creator Elena Gratton
  • Added Creator Heather Hines
  • Added Creator Christina Grozinger
  • Added Gratton et al_landscape factors_bumble bee pathogens.zip
  • Updated License Show Changes
    License
    • https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
  • Published
  • Updated

Version 2
published

  • Created
  • Updated Keyword, Related URLs Show Changes
    Keyword
    • Anthophila, Disease, Epidemiology, Landscape ecology, Management
    Related URLs
    • https://doi.org/10.1111/icad.12773
  • Deleted Gratton et al_landscape factors_bumble bee pathogens.zip
  • Added README.csv
  • Added Gratton et al_landscape factors_bumble bee pathogen.zip
  • Published
  • Updated
  • Updated Description Show Changes
    Description
    • Pathogens and parasites are considered important drivers of declines of wild bumble bee populations. Transmission of pathogens and parasites can be influenced by numerous abiotic and biotic factors, such as floral resource availability, inter/intraspecific pollinator interactions, land use change, climate, and exposure to pesticides . Identifying the key factors in the landscape to address to reduce disease burden in bees is thus challenging. We evaluated loads of common bee viruses Black Queen Cell Virus (BQCV) and Deformed Wing Virus (DWV) in the bumble bee Bombus impatiens, as well as the honey bee Apis meliferra, and loads of bumble bee parasites Vairimorpha bombi and Crithidia bombi in B. impatiens, from sites representing diverse habitat types and quality across North Carolina. We assessed relationships between pathogen loads and land cover characteristics, floral quality metrics, bee community diversity/richness metrics, and weather variables to determine which landscape factors best explained variation in pathogen loads. We compared our results with a comparable dataset from Pennsylvania. The data support latitudinal difference in pathogen loads but that pathogen loads otherwise tend to be influenced by landscape factors similarly between states. In North Carolina bumble bees, there was very low prevalence of DWV (14% of samples) and no Vairimorpha (0% of samples) and C. bombi showed consistently moderate loads across North Carolina (99% of samples) but more variation in loads in Pennsylvania . Directionality of pathogen incidence by landscape factors for both bee species generally mirrored results from Pennsylvania, however, BQCV loads were impacted differently by floral resource availability metrics by species and region. Honey bees and bumble bees in North Carolina showed similar trends, but correlations were weaker for bumble bees. Together with data from the literature, our results suggest honey bee density and percent developed land tend to be associated with increased pathogen loads in North American bumble bees, but floral availability metrics and community composition and diversity have mixed effects on pathogen loads.
    • Pathogens and parasites are considered important drivers of declines of wild bumble bee populations. Transmission of pathogens and parasites can be influenced by numerous abiotic and biotic factors, such as floral resource availability, inter/intraspecific pollinator interactions, land use change, climate, and exposure to pesticides . Identifying the key factors in the landscape to address to reduce disease burden in bees is thus challenging. We evaluated loads of common bee viruses Black Queen Cell Virus (BQCV) and Deformed Wing Virus (DWV) in the bumble bee Bombus impatiens, as well as the honey bee Apis meliferra, and loads of bumble bee parasites Vairimorpha bombi and Crithidia bombi in B. impatiens, from sites representing diverse habitat types and quality across North Carolina. We assessed relationships between pathogen loads and land cover characteristics, floral quality metrics, bee community diversity/richness metrics, and weather variables to determine which landscape factors best explained variation in pathogen loads. We compared our results with a comparable dataset from Pennsylvania. The data support latitudinal difference in pathogen loads but that pathogen loads otherwise tend to be influenced by landscape factors similarly between states. In North Carolina bumble bees, there was very low prevalence of DWV (14% of samples) and no Vairimorpha (0% of samples) and C. bombi showed consistently moderate loads across North Carolina (99% of samples) but more variation in loads in Pennsylvania . Directionality of pathogen incidence by landscape factors for both bee species generally mirrored results from Pennsylvania, however, BQCV loads were impacted differently by floral resource availability metrics by species and region. Honey bees and bumble bees in North Carolina showed similar trends, but correlations were weaker for bumble bees. Together with data from the literature, our results suggest honey bee density and percent developed land tend to be associated with increased pathogen loads in North American bumble bees, but floral availability metrics and community composition and diversity have mixed effects on pathogen loads.
    • Version 2 provides the following updates: The Kruskal-Wallice tests were replaced with individual mixed-effects models looking at each comparison specifically; the original Figure 3 was removed; some individual statistical comparisons of honey bee pathogen loads were removed as they were determined outside the scope of the project; p-value matrices were created for the correlation matrices; and individual mixed effects models were run to compare pathogen loads between the Pennsylvania 2020 data to North Carolina 2022.