Saul Ascher’s Critique of Kant and Fichte's Novel Antisemitism: Its Implications for Kantian Cosmopolitanism

Some scholars have responded to the increasingly widespread concerns about Immanuel Kant’s racism by promoting his cosmopolitanism as if the two were self-evidently incompatible, but his particular form of cosmopolitanism has its own history of difficulties when it comes to both racism and anti-Judaism. These concerns can be grounded historically if one links his 1784 essay on history with his account of cosmopolitanism in his 1793 lectures on the metaphysics of morals, where he criticized Jews for failing to embrace cosmopolitanism. Kant’s attack on the Jews was in line with Johann Gottlieb Fichte’s attack on them that had provoked Saul Ascher, a young Jewish Kantian, to accuse Fichte of inventing a new form of anti-Judaism. In this essay I reaffirm my rejection of the widespread claim that Kant toward the end of his life abandoned his belief in a racial hierarchy. I also demonstrate that he used the idea of cosmopolitanism as a tool not only against non-whites, but also against Jews. Kant’s cosmopolitanism should not be presented as the corrective to his racism, but as a new and dangerous addition to his earlier focus on inferiority.

Files

Metadata

Work Title Saul Ascher’s Critique of Kant and Fichte's Novel Antisemitism: Its Implications for Kantian Cosmopolitanism
Access
Open Access
Creators
  1. Robert Lambert Bernasconi
License In Copyright (Rights Reserved)
Work Type Article
Publisher
  1. Eco-Ethica
Publication Date August 1, 2021
Deposited November 16, 2021

Versions

Analytics

Collections

This resource is currently not in any collection.

Work History

Version 1
published

  • Created
  • Added Ascher_ecoethica_2_july_2021.docx
  • Added Creator Robert Lambert Bernasconi
  • Published
  • Updated
  • Updated
  • Updated