(In)justice on Ice: Valieva and International Sport Governing Bodies’ Justice Duties Toward Underage Athletes

After two years of discussions and revisions, the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) published the 2021 World Anti-Doping Code on June 16, 2020. Among the most significant additions to this iteration of the Code was the inclusion of new categories of athletes subject to differential treatment by WADA, including the “protected person” category. In this paper, we examine the recent case of figure skater Kamila Valeryevna Valieva, the first athlete given differential treatment due to her being categorized as a “protected person.” We apply a relational justice framework to the case to provide a nuanced, descriptive analysis of the case generally, and the application of the “protected person” category in particular.We first describe details of the athlete, her performances and anti-doping rule violation, and the “protected person” category, to provide context. We then describe and analyze the relations between several institutional actors, principally WADA and the International Court for the Arbitration of Sport (CAS), the athlete and her team, and other figure skating athletes at the Beijing Winter Olympic Games. To do so, we use two concepts of justice, conservative and ideal, and their component parts, entitlement, desert, and need.Our description and analyses demonstrate that (1) WADA’s notions of justice are essentially conservative, while CAS acted toward more ideal notions, creating a fundamental disagreement in what was owed and to whom. We show (2) that CAS’ decision may have nonetheless caused harm to the athlete, raising questions about the efficacy and capability of the “protected person” category. Finally, (3) our analyses show the influence that notions of justice necessarily have these actors shape each other, thus change the sporting institutions and activities themselves.

Files

Metadata

Work Title (In)justice on Ice: Valieva and International Sport Governing Bodies’ Justice Duties Toward Underage Athletes
Access
Open Access
Creators
  1. Brett Diaz
  2. Marcus Campos
  3. Matija Škerbić
  4. Cam Mallett
  5. Francisco Javier Lopez Frias
Keyword
  1. Protected persons
  2. Anti-doping
  3. Underage athletes
  4. Justice
  5. Olympics
License In Copyright (Rights Reserved)
Work Type Article
Publisher
  1. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy
Publication Date July 22, 2022
Publisher Identifier (DOI)
  1. https://doi.org/10.1080/17511321.2022.2099962
Deposited January 30, 2023

Versions

Analytics

Collections

This resource is currently not in any collection.

Work History

Version 1
published

  • Created
  • Added In_justice_on_Ice_Valieva_and_International_Sport_Governing_Bodies_Justice_Duties_Toward_Underage_Athletes.pdf
  • Added Creator Brett Diaz
  • Added Creator Marcus Campos
  • Added Creator Matija Škerbić
  • Added Creator Cam Mallett
  • Added Creator Francisco Javier Lopez Frias
  • Published
  • Updated Keyword, Publication Date Show Changes
    Keyword
    • Protected persons, Anti-doping, Underage athletes, Justice, Olympics
    Publication Date
    • 2022-01-01
    • 2022-07-22